Profitability of regulated infrastructure
How the returns of New Zealand's regulated infrastructure businesses compare with the cost of capital their prices were set on, by sector and by business, 2015–2025.
Sectors at a glance
Each row is a sector. Select one to list its businesses below.
- Gap
- Return minus benchmark, in percentage points (pp). Above zero means a sector earned more than its benchmark, which on its own isn't evidence of excess profit.
- Benchmark
- The cost of capital its prices were set on, adjusted for the inflation that actually happened.
- Revenue
- A year's revenue after costs passed straight through to customers, for scale.
| Sector | Revenue a year | Gap: average and each year | Average gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1.44b | +0.0 pp | ||
| $400m | −0.6 pp | ||
| $284m | −0.1 pp | ||
| $858m | −0.4 pp | ||
| $1.06b | −0.5 pp | ||
| $472m | −0.4 pp |
Year above benchmark Year below Part year Average Years run top to bottom, 2015–2025
Revenue is averaged over the years shown: $4.51b a year in all. Fibre starts in 2022.
What stands out
- Over time, sectors are close to their benchmark. Over 2015–2025, every sector averaged within 1 pp of its benchmark, from −0.6 pp to +0.0 pp.
- Recent years are below their benchmark. Over 2021–2025, every sector averaged below its benchmark, Transpower (−2.9 pp) and airports (−2.4 pp) by most.
- Inflation explains much of Transpower's shortfall. In 2022, inflation lifted Transpower's benchmark from 5.7% to 9.5%, but its return only from 4.5% to 5.2%: its assets aren't revalued with inflation, so its return doesn't rise with it. The price-regulated lines companies kept pace, their return rising from 3.7% to 9.2% against 3.8% to 9.3%.
- Airports swing most. Airports ranged from +3.7 pp in 2024 to −9.4 pp in 2022, when COVID-19 cut passenger numbers. They set their own prices, so their benchmark is a reference, not a limit.
- Few businesses are consistently above or below. Over 2021–2025, only Horizon Networks and Northpower Fibre were more than 1 pp above their benchmark every year, and only Transpower more than 1 pp below.
Businesses: Electricity lines (price-regulated)
Each row is a business. Select one to see what made up its return and what it said about it.
| Business | Revenue a year | Gap: average and each year | Average gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $411m | −0.6 pp | ||
| $280m | +0.0 pp | ||
| $178m | +1.0 pp | ||
| $110m | +0.5 pp | ||
| $100m | +0.7 pp | ||
| $77.6m | −1.5 pp | ||
| $44.5m | +1.1 pp | ||
| $39.8m | −0.7 pp | ||
| $35.3m | −0.2 pp | ||
| $34.3m | +0.0 pp | ||
| $27.4m | −0.1 pp | ||
| $27.1m | +0.3 pp | ||
| $26.7m | +0.4 pp | ||
| $24.4m | +1.8 pp | ||
| $13.6m | +0.5 pp | ||
| $10.9m | +1.1 pp | ||
| $6.4m | +0.5 pp |
One year Part year Average Scale ±6 pp; arrows go beyond it
Method
- A comparison with a benchmark, not a profit test. Each business’s return is set against the cost of capital its prices were set on. A positive gap isn’t on its own evidence of excess profit: inflation, timing and one-off items all affect it.
- Return (ROI). What a business earned in a year on the value of its regulated assets, after tax, as it disclosed it. A return isn’t profit divided by assets: it is the rate at which the year’s cash flows and the change in asset value add up.
- Benchmark (WACC). The cost of capital for the pricing period, adjusted from the inflation the Reserve Bank forecast when it was set to the inflation that happened. Airports use the rate from their own price-setting, with the inflation they priced with (before that is available, the Commission’s annual rate). Exempt lines companies, which are community-owned, and the fibre providers other than Chorus are compared with the rate set for the price-regulated businesses.
- Averages. A sector’s yearly gap weights its businesses by asset value; its average is the mean of those yearly gaps. A business’s average is the mean of its own yearly gaps.
- Sectors. Electricity lines are split into price-regulated and exempt businesses, gas distribution and transmission are combined, and fibre combines Chorus with three local providers from 2022. Powerco is listed twice, once for electricity and once for gas.
- Revenue. Operating revenue and other regulated income, less costs passed straight through to customers, in nominal dollars, averaged over the years that have it. A sector’s year counts only when every business in it has revenue; part-year disclosures, and the gas pipelines before First Gas bought them, have none. For airports it includes leases and concessions on regulated assets, so it is higher than the aeronautical revenue in their accounts.
- What made up a return. Each item is in percentage points of the asset base, beside the median for the same sector and year. For electricity lines, gas pipelines, fibre and airports from 2019, items come from the return’s own calculation; for Transpower and earlier airports, from the accounts. Vanilla ROI, which businesses often quote, leaves out the tax saving on interest and is usually higher.
- Points to note and comments. Notes flag things that affect a year’s gap, such as part-year disclosures, incentive payments and asset bases not revalued with inflation. Comments are the business’s own words from its annual disclosure, shortened to at most 2,400 characters; they are its explanation, not an independent finding.
- Data. Commerce Commission, information disclosures and cost of capital determinations, and the Reserve Bank’s Monetary Policy Statements for inflation forecasts. Figures are derived by NZ Infrastructure Insights and are not endorsed by the Commission; businesses’ comments are excluded from the CC BY 4.0 licence. The ZIP has every business and sector year, with a readme.