Electricity distribution scorecard

A quick look at how New Zealand's electricity lines companies (EDBs) compare on cost, reliability, losses and looking after their assets, allowing for how big and how spread out each network is.

Scores at a glance

Each row is a lines company. Click a company row to see what's behind its score.

Score
Out of 100, where 100 is best and 50 typical. Size and density are allowed for (asset age, condition and renewal aren't adjusted). The four areas count equally.
Band
The range covers the middle 90% of ranks as we randomly vary the weight on each of the four areas. Strong or Weak means that whole range stays in the top or bottom third.
Groups
Thirds by ICPs per km of line, which is how the table is listed: sparse below 7.5, intermediate 7.5–12.6, dense 12.6+.

Scores compare each EDB with all EDBs.

Scroll the table sideways for the scores.

Scores out of 100, higher is better, compared with all EDBs, grouped by network density
EDBICPs/km ICPs per km Connections per kilometre of line. Each home or business connected is an ICP (installation control point).Low means a spread-out, mostly rural network; high means a compact, urban one. It sets the density group.Band (rank range) Band (rank range) How settled the rank is. We re-rank every EDB 10,000 times, each time weighting the four areas differently; the numbers are the middle 90% of the ranks it gets.Strong or Weak: that whole range is in the top or bottom third. Middle: it overlaps, so treat its position as uncertain.Overall Overall score The average of the four area scores, out of 100.50 is typical and higher is better, compared with all EDBs. Size and density are allowed for (asset age, condition and renewal aren't adjusted).Cost25%Reliability25%Utilisation and losses25%Asset management25%
Sparse below 7.5 ICPs/km
OtagoNet OtagoNet Poor-condition grades likely on the wrong scale: Pole Mounted Transformer 2024 (0.32% vs usual 39%); Wood poles 2025 (0.0042% vs usual 24%). Without those years: asset score 32 (not 34), rank unchanged.4.2Strong 1–57480849634
The Power Company The Power Company Poor-condition grades likely on the wrong scale: Wood poles 2025 (0.011% vs usual 24%). Without those years: asset score about the same, rank unchanged.4.2Strong 1–47080757054
Scanpower Scanpower No zone substations: takes supply from Transpower at distribution voltage, so step-down losses and costs sit upstream. Flatters its loss ratio and cost.2025 loss ratio 0.4% vs usual 7.3%: implausible, likely a disclosure error. Scored on the five-year median, so no effect.6.4Strong 4–86371824356
Centralines 4.9Middle 6–155788414157
Network Waitaki 7.0Middle 7–205227844849
The Lines Company 5.4Middle 9–195038415764
Firstlight Network 6.5Middle 8–25498874556
EA Networks 6.6Middle 10–274312911851
Buller Electricity 7.4Middle 19–273921165958
Westpower 6.4Weak 25–292916571626
Intermediate 7.5–12.6 ICPs/km
Powerco 12.3Strong 1–66682685064
Network Tasman 11.3Middle 4–156098624632
Northpower 10.2Middle 5–215357116479
Waipa Networks Waipa Networks Poor-condition grades likely on the wrong scale: Distribution OH Open Wire Conductor 2024 (0.027% vs usual 4%); Distribution OH Open Wire Conductor 2025 (0.027% vs usual 4%). Without those years: asset score 45 (not 49), rank 17 (not 16).No zone substations (has 33 km of subtransmission): takes supply from Transpower at distribution voltage, so step-down losses and costs sit upstream. Flatters its loss ratio and cost.12.4Middle 9–235075126249
Horizon Networks 9.7Middle 12–264577272948
Alpine Energy 7.7Middle 10–264511844836
MainPower NZ 8.4Middle 18–264254433238
Marlborough Lines 7.7Middle 16–27397704830
Top Energy 8.0Weak 27–29261604346
Dense 12.6+ ICPs/km
Nelson Electricity Nelson Electricity 91% underground. Reliability isn't adjusted for undergrounding, so the score keeps any benefit; the capital cost shows in totex through a larger asset base (RAB) per unit of network size: $30,653, against a median of $25,103.31.3Strong 2–56977867045
Orion NZ 18.4Middle 3–1460461004353
Wellington Electricity 35.9Middle 7–175673793837
Unison Networks 12.6Middle 7–185154297350
WEL Networks 17.4Middle 10–175045396255
Electra 19.5Middle 12–175050435949
Electricity Invercargill Electricity Invercargill 92% underground. Reliability isn't adjusted for undergrounding, so the score keeps any benefit; the capital cost shows in totex through a larger asset base (RAB) per unit of network size: $32,064, against a median of $25,103.26.4Middle 16–224654305943
Aurora Energy 15.0Middle 15–27405394374
Vector Lines 31.1Weak 22–253923364354
Counties Energy 13.2Weak 21–283725144563

· 50 is typical

What stands out

  • The top is fairly settled. OtagoNet, The Power Company, Nelson Electricity, Powerco and Scanpower are in the top quarter almost whatever the weighting (97–100% of weightings), and no one beats any of them on all four areas.
  • The bottom is pretty settled. Westpower and Top Energy stay in the bottom five however you weight the scores (at least 95% of weightings), and 9–15 EDBs do better than each of them on all four areas.
  • Most are too close to call. Only 5 EDBs stay in the top third and 4 in the bottom third across the middle 90% of weightings. The other 20 overlap too much to put in order (a typical rank range is 9 places), so treat them as a group.
  • A good overall score can hide a weak spot. OtagoNet (asset management 34) and Northpower (reliability 11) rank in the top half but have one area 30+ points below their overall score. Averaging lets the strong areas cover for it.
  • Most all-round. The Power Company has no weak spot: its lowest score is 54 (asset management). Every other top-ten EDB has something at 50 or below.

One EDB against the rest

OtagoNet

OtagoNet A sparse network: 4.2 ICPs per km, 19,312 ICPs, 4,653 km of line, 6% underground.Consumer trust (via The Power Company); price-quality regulated.In the top quarter in 100% of weightings; no EDB beats it on all four areas.Poor-condition grades likely on the wrong scale: Pole Mounted Transformer 2024 (0.32% vs usual 39%); Wood poles 2025 (0.0042% vs usual 24%). Without those years: asset score 32 (not 34), rank unchanged.

Showing the top-ranked EDB.

Overall
74 rank 1 of 29
Band (rank range)
Strong 1–5
Within sparse networks
67 rank 1 of 10

OtagoNet other EDBs median top quarter of all EDBs typical for its size and density (1.00×) better →

Cost80

Opex per ICP Opex per ICP Running costs (operating spending) per connection a year, in today’s dollars.

$555 as disclosed · log scale

0.67×percentile 100

Totex with capital services per √(ICPs × km) Totex with capital services per √(ICPs × km) Running costs plus a yearly charge for the money tied up in the network, per unit of network size, √(ICPs × km). It follows the Commerce Commission’s productivity study by CEPA.

$3,922 as disclosed · log scale

0.96×percentile 61

Reliability84

Unplanned SAIDI Unplanned SAIDI SAIDI: the average minutes each customer is without power from unplanned outages a year. Storms are included.

204 min as disclosed · log scale

0.56×percentile 86

Unplanned SAIFI Unplanned SAIFI SAIFI: the average number of unplanned outages each customer has a year. Storms are included.

2.11 as disclosed · log scale

0.67×percentile 82

Utilisation and losses96

Loss ratio Loss ratio The share of electricity entering the network that is lost on the way, mostly as heat in lines and transformers. The median of the yearly figures.

3.9% as disclosed · log scale

0.81×percentile 100

Maximum demand ÷ distribution transformer capacity Maximum demand ÷ distribution transformer capacity Peak demand as a share of the capacity of the transformers that supply homes and businesses. Higher means capacity is better used, up to 0.4; above that counts the same.

0.28 as disclosed · log scale · capped at 0.4

1.17×percentile 93

Asset management34

Assets installed before 1980 (45+ years old) Assets installed before 1980 (45+ years old) The share of the network’s main asset groups installed before 1980 (45+ years old), from the 2025 disclosures.

2025 disclosure

23.5%percentile 71

Assets in poor condition (grades H1–H2) Assets in poor condition (grades H1–H2) The share of the network’s main asset groups the EDB itself grades as at or near the end of their life (grades H1–H2).

11.5%percentile 14

Renewal capex ÷ network depreciation Renewal capex ÷ network depreciation Spending on replacing old assets, compared with how fast the network wears out on paper (depreciation). Around 1 keeps pace; above 1.5 counts the same.

capped at 1.5

0.95percentile 43

Totex forecast error Totex forecast error How far actual spending (capital and operating) missed the EDB’s own forecast at the start of the year, over or under, averaged over the years. Lower means steadier planning.

17.9% as disclosed · log scale

1.68×percentile 7
Values for every EDB (adjusted)
Values as scored for every EDB and scored measure
EDBOpex /ICPTotex /unitUnplanned SAIDIUnplanned SAIFILossesDemand ÷ capacity45+ years oldPoor conditionRenewal ÷ depnForecast error
OtagoNet0.67×0.96×0.56×0.67×0.81×1.17×23.5%11.5%0.951.68×
The Power Company0.71×0.94×0.53×0.87×1.00×1.41×32.6%3.8%0.820.55×
Nelson Electricity0.77×0.96×0.56×0.56×0.94×1.06×39.6%0.3%0.560.85×
Powerco0.83×0.89×0.76×0.74×1.00×1.02×25.7%5.9%1.220.68×
Scanpower0.91×0.91×0.73×0.42×0.96×0.94×9.7%9.9%1.041.03×
Orion NZ1.04×1.00×0.29×0.37×0.93×0.89×28.7%1.3%0.720.89×
Network Tasman0.70×0.66×0.77×0.81×1.09×1.06×37.1%1.7%0.851.99×
Centralines0.83×0.81×0.99×1.22×0.95×0.90×30.5%5.3%1.500.98×
Wellington Electricity0.87×0.92×0.61×0.72×1.12×1.05×43.2%5.0%0.961.06×
Northpower1.13×0.85×1.99×2.35×0.96×1.06×23.8%4.3%1.500.60×
Network Waitaki1.21×1.10×0.46×0.73×0.97×0.99×24.8%5.5%1.261.58×
Unison Networks1.00×0.97×2.30×0.98×0.84×1.00×26.0%13.3%1.340.91×
WEL Networks1.03×1.06×1.20×1.14×0.92×1.00×26.2%0.4%0.981.25×
Electra1.04×0.97×0.87×1.29×1.06×1.11×30.6%3.5%1.091.17×
The Lines Company1.06×1.08×1.04×1.18×1.11×1.22×28.2%3.0%1.190.87×
Waipa Networks0.95×0.83×2.02×1.46×0.91×0.99×11.7%4.2%0.851.70×
Firstlight Network0.83×0.82×2.63×2.02×1.13×1.07×32.3%7.3%1.500.75×
Electricity Invercargill0.93×1.06×1.15×1.38×1.06×1.14×31.5%14.5%1.030.62×
Horizon Networks0.89×0.86×1.41×1.35×1.02×0.91×28.2%7.6%0.880.67×
Alpine Energy1.39×1.13×0.72×0.50×0.85×0.80×32.7%18.9%1.501.08×
EA Networks1.18×1.48×0.42×0.62×1.49×0.96×5.8%4.1%0.701.26×
MainPower NZ0.97×0.98×1.40×0.91×0.95×0.80×20.1%11.1%0.721.16×
Aurora Energy1.37×1.17×0.93×1.34×1.10×1.05×23.8%6.4%1.500.61×
Marlborough Lines1.30×1.22×0.73×0.78×0.82×0.79×26.4%10.8%0.631.03×
Vector Lines1.06×1.17×1.49×1.13×0.98×0.97×23.2%4.8%1.121.57×
Buller Electricity1.24×1.11×2.00×1.40×0.86×0.95×26.9%2.5%0.760.72×
Counties Energy1.12×1.15×1.59×2.21×0.92×0.86×9.4%7.6%1.501.24×
Westpower1.33×1.13×0.87×0.90×1.19×0.92×11.8%24.7%0.401.40×
Top Energy1.22×1.17×3.59×2.42×1.33×1.09×22.7%8.1%0.700.90×

What good looks like

Figures: median / top quarter, as disclosed, 2021–2025

What good looks like, as disclosed, by density group
MeasureAll EDBs29 EDBsSparse networksbelow 7.5 ICPs/km, 10 EDBs
Cost
Opex per ICP Opex per ICP Running costs (operating spending) per connection a year, in today’s dollars.lower is better$553 / $399 $726 / $587
Totex with capital services per √(ICPs × km) Totex with capital services per √(ICPs × km) Running costs plus a yearly charge for the money tied up in the network, per unit of network size, √(ICPs × km). It follows the Commerce Commission’s productivity study by CEPA.lower is better$4,353 / $3,815 $4,197 / $3,826
Reliability
Unplanned SAIDI Unplanned SAIDI SAIDI: the average minutes each customer is without power from unplanned outages a year. Storms are included.lower is better170 min / 98 min 199 min / 113 min
Unplanned SAIFI Unplanned SAIFI SAIFI: the average number of unplanned outages each customer has a year. Storms are included.lower is better1.62 / 1.13 1.86 / 1.29
Utilisation and losses
Loss ratio Loss ratio The share of electricity entering the network that is lost on the way, mostly as heat in lines and transformers. The median of the yearly figures.lower is better5.0% / 4.5% 6.9% / 5.1%
Maximum demand ÷ distribution transformer capacity Maximum demand ÷ distribution transformer capacity Peak demand as a share of the capacity of the transformers that supply homes and businesses. Higher means capacity is better used, up to 0.4; above that counts the same.higher is better0.27 / 0.29 0.25 / 0.28
Asset management
Assets installed before 1980 (45+ years old) Assets installed before 1980 (45+ years old) The share of the network’s main asset groups installed before 1980 (45+ years old), from the 2025 disclosures.lower is better26.2% / 23.2% 25.8% / 14.7%
Assets in poor condition (grades H1–H2) Assets in poor condition (grades H1–H2) The share of the network’s main asset groups the EDB itself grades as at or near the end of their life (grades H1–H2).lower is better5.5% / 3.8% 5.4% / 3.9%
Renewal capex ÷ network depreciation Renewal capex ÷ network depreciation Spending on replacing old assets, compared with how fast the network wears out on paper (depreciation). Around 1 keeps pace; above 1.5 counts the same.higher is better0.98 / 1.26 0.99 / 1.24
Totex forecast error Totex forecast error How far actual spending (capital and operating) missed the EDB’s own forecast at the start of the year, over or under, averaged over the years. Lower means steadier planning.lower is better9.0% / 7.0% 11.8% / 8.8%

Method